Jump to content

Minor third

Most bird song isn’t what we’d recognise as regular musical intervals, but there are exceptions. A peculiarity of those exceptions is how often the ‘minor third’ seems to crop up.

Though known by many from European cuckoos, more surprising is how – it seems to me – the minor third seems to be the interval of choice across a range of species. Is this fair? This web page is to put my observation in writing and to invite comment and debate.

Musical intervals

Firstly, a quick note for non-musicians. A musical interval is the gap between notes. Sing the first two notes of ‘Amazing Grace’ and you’re just sung a fourth. ‘Baa baa black sheep’ kicks off with a fifth. Beach Boys fans hear a sixth as Brian Wilson sings ‘Surfer Girl’. If that doesn’t work for you, ‘My Bonny lies over the ocean’ also starts with a sixth.

So what about the minor third? It’s the interval of the second 'da da da DA' of Beethoven’s Fifth (the first is a major third). It’s the slightly poignant yet penetrating ‘Ne na ne na’ of an old-fashioned ambulance – before today’s wailing sirens were introduced; the children's traditional playground cry "naa naa na naa naaa" is based around a minor third .

An octave is the interval between one musical pitch and another with half or double its frequency (depending on whether you go down or up.) These notes starts from the assumption that to divide an octave into eight notes (12 equal semitones) is a musical structure made by western man. (The Arabic classical scale has 17, 19, or even 24 notes – perhaps why music from a minaret sounds uncomfortable to western ears).

But are there any grounds in physics or nature to argue that our notes are more natural than that – or copied from nature in some way?

The cuckoo

The minor third is the cu-coo of a cuckoo in spring. This is fairly well-known. It crops up in classical music (see right): Google it and you’ll find a list of references including a blog at Springwatch.

But the sound doesn’t stay like that all season.

Cuckoos are known to change their song during the spring and early summer – see the rhyme on the right. The interval moves, roughly, from a minor third to a major third to a fourth. This is not clear-cut: sometimes you can hear the later, bigger intervals early in the season; in May, to hear a mixture is not unusual. Sometimes the intervals aren’t completely clean, to our ears.

But these are details. The best-known and much loved interval, at the start of spring, is a minor third.

Ortolan bunting

ortolan bunting
Ortolan bunting (photo by Steve Cale, who is a Norfolk-based artist; do have a look at his super pictures on his website)

Many years ago, I recall Honeyguide leader Robin Hamilton enthusing over the ortolan bunting's ‘Beethoven’s Fifth’ song. The rhythm recalls Beethoven's famous da - da - da - daah. It’s hardly a top songster, but listen carefully and the interval (as I hear it) is also a minor third. Sometimes it goes up: sometimes it goes down. But my experience in the field is that it’s always a minor third – though that’s not clear on the recording on Jean Roché’s ‘Bird Songs and Calls of Britain and Europe’ CD set.

Common crane

Two birds, one interval: an intriguing link. But there are more. The so-called ‘unison’ bugling of common cranes is, in fact, close harmony. According to Birds of the Western Palearctic, it’s another minor third – though again that not clear on the recording on Jean Roché’s CD set.

This call is often made on or near the nest, and when courting, but also frequently out of the breeding season when crane pairs are feeding or walking around. It seems to be a contact call, acting as reassurance when the other bird joins in. More on European cranes in Norfolk here.

South African birds

In autumn 2009, I was in South Africa’s Garden Route. We heard red-chested cuckoos (Piet my Vrou bird) , a widespread bird species south of the Sahara, on several occasions. The song goes down the scale from (roughly) C sharp, C natural, B flat, like ‘Three Blind Mice’ played in a minor key. Hear it here or here.

From its top note to its bottom note: a minor third, again, albeit with one extra note in the middle.

Then, at the rhinoceros hide in Addo Elephant National Park, a bird, probably a bokmakierie (a kind of shrike) was singing the introduction to Beethoven's Fifth symphony. Sadly, I couldn’t see the bird to confirm its ID.

What’s the link?

Why should the minor third crop up like this? So far as I know, this connection hasn’t been described before and there are no clear theories or conclusions.

The purpose of bird song is to mark territory and to attract a mate. Given birds’ relatively limited vocal range, perhaps larger musical intervals come less easily, and a simple tone or semi-tone is less distinctive for communication.

So is the minor third be a ‘natural’ interval that comes easily to birds? Surely that’s too anthropomorphic? Perhaps it’s just coincidence.

I welcome comments, information and opinions! To email, click here.

Back to nature notes Chris Durdin, February 2010, with later updates

Also on a musical note - though nothing to do with nature - who are your favourite backing singers? Honeyguide's Chris Durdin reveals his Top 10 here.

Music drawings on this page copied from various internet sites: these illustrate a minor third, or thirds, in various ways.

 

Wikipedia's pages on the minor third are here

 

cuckoo

Cuckoo picture above from the RSPB’s A – Z of birds here – you can also hear the song here.

The cuckoo in classical music includes:

● Beethoven's Pastoral Symphony

● Handel in his The Cuckoo

● Saint-Saëns in Carnival of the Animals

● Delius with On Hearing the First Cuckoo in Spring

● A short keyboard piece by Louis-Claude Daquin (French, 1694-1772) entitled Le Coucou

Are there other examples?

Curiously, the cuckoo is not one of the 13 birds featured in the Catalogue d'oiseaux by Olivier Messiaen (1908-1992) (see Wikipedia here)

 

The cuckoo rhyme seems to come in different forms:

Cuckoo, cuckoo, what do you do?
In April I open my bill;
In May I sing all day;
In June I change my tune;
In July away I fly;
In August away I must.

"The Cuckoo comes in April, it sings its song in May, in the middle of June it changes its tune
and in July it flies away."

"The Cuckoo comes in April, sings his song in May, changes his tune in the month of June, and then he flies away".

More on the cuckoo on Wikipedia here

 

Piet-my-vrou or red-chested cuckoo

Red-chested cuckoo

Bokmakierie

Bokmakierie

South African bird pictures with the kind permission of Jill Adams

Spanish postscript: in Extremadura in March 2010, hoopoes were duetting with a musical interval of a fourth.

France postscript: in the Dordogne in May 2010, the many cuckoos we heard all seemed to be singing with a major third interval - perhaps as it was part way through the season.

American postscripts: Nick near Chicago, USA (June 2011) drew my attention to the song of the black-capped chickadee. The 'typical' song here is a major second. However Joanne Garton in Vermont (April 2015) notes that the chick-a-dee's 'Fee Bee' call or 'Hey Sweetie' call can also be a minor third and that seems right on YouTube here.

Facebook Honeyguide
... where there are many holiday photos to enjoy.

Atol protected

The air holidays shown are ATOL Protected by the Civil Aviation Authority. Our ATOL number is ATOL 3253. ATOL Protection extends primarily to customers who book and pay in the United Kingdom. Click on the ATOL logo if you want to know more.

Helping you enjoy wildlife – Helping you protect wildlife